Evil, Hostile Grumpy Listeners? Think Again


I hated Kyle Sisk*. A notorious bully, Kyle punctuated my grade school years with misery. He would tease me about my weight, purposely rattle me with shocking language, delight in making me look foolish at every opportunity. Kyle had scary, penetrating eyes and sharp, jagged teeth that looked, appropriately, like fangs. He even had his own evil henchman named Eddie who would follow him everywhere, laughing a conspiratorial little laugh asking, "Heh, heh, what are we going to do next, Kyle? Heh, heh." (All Eddie was missing was a hump.) A typical encounter was the time I was walking home from school and Kyle and Eddie pounced from behind some bushes, grabbed my books and threw them in the mud. Even worse, they snatched my precious, brand new little purse and threw it into the branches of a tree, far out of reach. They then ran off cackling in triumph. I, purseless, limped home in tears.

A Sad Reprieve

This type of treatment continued all through grade school. I enjoyed the respite of summertime before we started at our new junior high school but September came and with it, my sense of dread at seeing Kyle again. I was given a reprieve, but an unwelcome one. That first week of school, my father died suddenly of a massive heart attack. I stayed home from school for about a week for the funeral and family visits. My first day back, the teachers wanted to take it easy on me so they gave me the coveted duty of going to each classroom and placing the absentee list on each teacher's desk. I felt special to be excused from class and was enjoying my rounds when I came to Mr. Lester's science class. I entered the room and my heart stopped. There, sitting right next to Mr. Lester's desk was Evil Incarnate himself, Kyle. There was no avoiding him--he had seen me come in--so I braced myself for whatever abuse he was no doubt preparing, but as I got closer I noticed that he didn't have his usual smug expression. He was looking down at his desk sheepishly. Very odd. As I lay the paper on the teacher's desk, Kyle looked up at me with big, soft eyes and in a timid, tentative voice said, "I'm sorry your old man croaked."

A State of Shock

I was stunned. Not from the inelegance of the sentiment, but rather from the realization that Kyle-even KYLE-had the capacity to feel and express compassion. "I'm sorry your old man croaked" wasn't exactly poetic, but to me it was the sweetest expression of kindness I had ever heard. It was in that moment that I realized that everyone, no matter how intimidating, has good in there somewhere.

A Lesson for Speaking

I think we need to remember this when we speak to our audiences. We look out and see grumpy frowns or intimidating scowls but even those listeners have hearts and the potential to connect with us. We might not be able to connect right away--maybe not ever--but just about everyone has that basic human spark of goodness through which we all connect. Besides, you've heard the old saying, "Behind every jerk is a sad story." We need to remember that the most intimidating, obnoxious audience members you will ever face most likely got to be that way because of pain. Looking back, Kyle's bullying no doubt stemmed from his miserable home life. His lashing out at me on the schoolyard is not much different than the heckler at a comedy club or a nit-picking critic at a presentation. Frustration, disappointment, powerlessness-they all lead to acting out, and as speakers we're sometimes on the receiving end. But no matter how bad the behavior, those difficult listeners in your audience still have the capacity to support you.

I think we can foster their humanness by being the first to reach out in a spirit of openness and service. When we speak to serve, with a genuine desire to do good for our listeners, we increase the likelihood that their negative energy will diminish in favor of a positive connection. There's no guarantee that they will reach back to support us, and they may even keep up their offensive behavior, but let's at least allow for the possibility that they might not be as evil as we think.

*Name has been changed to protect privacy

About The Author

Melissa Lewis turns traditional thinking about public speaking upside down to give people more comfort, confidence and charisma in front of groups. She is a former comic actress, a certified facilitator of SPEAKING CIRCLES( , president-elect of the National Speakers Association Kansas City Chapter and author of the soon-to-be-released book, Upside Down Speaking. For more information call (913) 341-1241 or visit www.upsidedownspeaking.com.

melissa@upsidedownspeaking.com







Related News



Johnson’s leadership already proven - Suffolk News-Herald

Johnson’s leadership already proven
Suffolk News-Herald, VA -4 hours ago
... and Linda Johnson is the only candidate who has the experience, who has provided leadership, who understands the problems that come with running a city ...
Hard work should earn another termSuffolk News-Herald
Fiscal crisis calls for strong experienceSuffolk News-Herald
all 5 news articles

Obama offers leadership on financial woes - InTheNews.co.uk

BBC News

Obama offers leadership on financial woes
InTheNews.co.uk, UK -Oct 10, 2008
Full Story Barack Obama has offered what he says is the "real leadership" needed in Washington to guide the United States through its financial crisis. ...
Video: McCain Links Obama To AyersCBS
WASHINGTON: A new Obama campaign ad questions John McCain's ...FOXNews
US Presidential Campaign Tone Becomes Increasingly NegativeVoice of America
Boston Globe - AFP
all 5,262 news articles

Police official meets with Akko’s Arab leadership - Ynetnews

Times Online

Police official meets with Akko’s Arab leadership
Ynetnews, Israel -13 hours ago
The police announced that they are in continual contact with representatives from Akko’s Jewish leadership including Mayor Shimon Lankry and the various ...
Facebook Group Opens: Jews Condemning Jews Who Riot in Acco Akko ...Israel News Agency
Livni urges calm after Arabs, Jews clash in IsraelReuters
all 870 news articles

Guam's Andersen Air Force Base Team Members Attend Leadership Seminar - Pacific News Center

Guam's Andersen Air Force Base Team Members Attend Leadership Seminar
Pacific News Center -4 hours ago
ANDERSEN AIR FORCE BASE, Guam - Leading, supporting, and collaborating with people is one of the greatest challenges any leader faces on their leadership...

Leadership experiment has makings of a mess - Austin American-Statesman

Leadership experiment has makings of a mess
Austin American-Statesman, TX -4 hours ago
By Mike Leggett A parrot and a monkey walk into a bar. The monkey, who's wearing a tuxedo, says to the bartender, "A priest, a rabbi and a deputy director ...

Nebraska Youth Beef Leadership Symposium convenes in mid-November - KTIV

Nebraska Youth Beef Leadership Symposium convenes in mid-November
KTIV, IA -13 hours ago
The sixth annual Nebraska Youth Beef Leadership Symposium is set for Nov. 15 through Nov. 17 at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. ...

MASON: AIDS Reform leadership needed - Washington Times

Washington Times

MASON: AIDS Reform leadership needed
Washington Times, DC -3 hours ago
Given his interest in foreign policy, I expected him to appreciate the importance of US leadership in the global fight against HIV, but I was surprised by ...


Obama fails to show leadership when needed - Hilton Head Island Packet

Obama fails to show leadership when needed
Hilton Head Island Packet, SC -1 hour ago
In the game of politics, one-up-manship is everything. Sen. John McCain just upped Sen. Barack Obama but good. Obama's first gaffe, of course, ...
High time to move beyond clichésAl-Ahram Weekly
Oprah Winfrey, Michelle Obama Joe and Jill Biden at Obama fund ...Chicago Sun-Times
all 1,652 news articles

Without real leadership, we face disaster - guardian.co.uk

Without real leadership, we face disaster
guardian.co.uk, UK -6 hours ago
Without collaboration and leadership, we face disaster. On Friday, there were terrifying signs that the contagion was spreading to the foreign exchange ...

Gay support group criticizes Mormon leadership - San Francisco Chronicle

Gay support group criticizes Mormon leadership
San Francisco Chronicle,  USA -5 hours ago
Leaders of a support group for gay and lesbian Mormons on Saturday criticized their church for its efforts to ban gay marriage in California. ...